Team Vision for Detailed Design Phase
Plan | Actual |
Update MaintainX and MaxPanda for testing by GCVM | Entered information relevant to GCVM in both MaintainX and MaxPanda |
Run limited test with GCVM to help select between the two options | Walked GCVM through basic MaintainX features and added Scott and Peter as administrators. |
Further update the selected option | MaintainX was selected to move forward with, we have worked to add features needed for implementation at GCVM |
Begin implementation | Planning to begin implementation first week of MSDII |
Progress Report
Plan
- Update MaintainX and MaxPanda for testing by GCVM
- Run limited test with GCVM to help select between the two options
- Further update the selected option
- Begin implementation
Accomplished
- Update MaintainX and MaxPanda for testing by GCVM
- Run limited test with GCVM to help select between the two options
- Further update the selected option
Remaining Tasks
- Implement system
- Train GCVM employees
- Add current work orders to begin archival process
- Get list of non historic buildings
- Get a list of job categories and building assets from Peter and Scott
Decisions Made
- GCVM will be using MaintainX
Questions
Prototyping, Engineering Analysis, Simulation
MaintainX allows for locations and images to be easily input.
MaintainX allows for the easy creation of New Work Orders with images, description, priority, assignment, location, and assets.
MaintainX allows input of employees or vendors in the vendors section. This provides them with an email and text of the work order they have been assigned to as well as a work history for the admin.
Iterative activities to demonstrate feasibility, including assumptions you made in your analyses or simulations. Have you completed sufficient analysis to ensure that your design will satisfy requirements? Have you included all usage scenarios in your modeling?
Drawings, Schematics, Flow Charts, Simulations
Please refer to the Preliminary Detailed Design Phase Design and Flowcharts section for all Schematics, Flow Charts ect. as nothing has changed since that review.
Bill of Material (BOM)
Similar to the System Level Review we have no actual materials that need to be purchased for this project due to it's online nature. We are currently trying out 2 CMMS software systems, one is free and one is costing us $39 dollars a month. When it comes time to transfer to the client we will discuss with them how the cost will be transferred to them opposed to us.
Test Plans
Test Number | Test Name | Description | Definition of Success | Engineering Requirement | Risks |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Ease of Access (Customer) | Check with the customer, allow them to test the system and work with it. | the system is simple and straightforward to use from the customer's point of view. | Dashboard view of jobs Able to accept multiple attachment types Able to notify when work needs to be done All management staff is able to use system | Customer decides late in the process that the system is too complicated |
2 | Customization | Use the system, see if it there is an option to customize things like buildings, locations, rooms, task types ect. | The system allows the addition of different buildings, roles, assets, and maintenance categories to make finding information easier | Must be able to track all 68 buildings | System could be overly complicated |
3 | Manager Controls | Use the system, make sure that there is an assignment for manager/administrator | The system allows the manager to do things like assign priority and make adjustments to the work orders. | Permission features for different users | Too little granularity in user permissions causing customer to compromise on permissions Too much granularity in customer permissions, causing confusion and errors by customer |
4 | Price | The cost of the system | Meets or is less than the customer's budget | Within budget | The system is out of the customers budget The system becomes out of customers budget |
5 | Reports | Test the report features in the system | The customer is happy with the reports that are generated and finds them useful | track all buildings | the feature to generate reports is locked behind a price wall |
6 | Ability to schedule jobs | Make sure that the system has the capability to have a job planned and notify the user when the time is coming for the job | The system has the capability to plan work and notify the user | increase planned maintenance | Job scheduling is either locked or more complex than desired |
7 | Ability to modify & update WO's | Make sure that the system has the ability to modify and update work orders after they're submitted | The system has the capability to let the manager modify the work orders after they've been submitted | Labor Tracking on Repairs | Workers can modify their own work orders |
Design and Flowcharts
The Flowchart is the same flowchart that was used in the Design Review. Please refer to the Preliminary Detailed Design Phase for the flowchart
Risk Assessment
ID | Category | Risk Item | Effect | Cause | Likelihood | Severity | Importance | Action to Minimize Risk | Owner |
What type of risk is this? | Describe the risk briefly | What is the effect on any or all of the project deliverables if the cause actually happens? | What are the possible cause(s) of this risk? | L | S | L*S | What action(s) will you take (and by when) to prevent, reduce the impact of, and/or transfer the risk of this occurring? | Who is responsible for following through on mitigation? | |
1 | Resource | Customer changes scope | New project proposal | Outside source has different idea | 3 | 6 | 18 | Meet/email customer bi-weekly | Shawn |
2 | Resource | Customer does not get back to us with relevant information | Can not move forward with project | Customer is busy to devote time to project | 9 | 3 | 27 | Assign tasks to customers in email | Shawn |
3 | Technical | Customer isn't happy with product | Unhappy customer | Product not what their looking for | 3 | 6 | 18 | Meet/email customer bi-weekly | Shawn |
4 | Technical | Failure to integrate with current system | Failed system | Lack of attention | 1 | 6 | 6 | Updated software with GCVM buildings - trialing | Team |
5 | Functional | Past repairs get lost | No history of repairs | Archive system not working | 3 | 6 | 18 | Experiment with small sample size of GCVM repairs | Team |
6 | Societal | Team member stops contributing | More work on others | Lack of motivation | 1 | 6 | 6 | Accept Risk | Team |
7 | Societal | Buildings isnt on a secure site | Information gets leaked | Not created on a secure site | 1 | 6 | 6 | Make sure a secure sight is used | Team |
8 | Societal | No feedback from benchmark companies | Less benchmark products | Companies not willing to work with us | 1 | 1 | 1 | Demo CMMS software | Connor |
9 | Societal | Price of subscription increases for bought software | GCVM can't afford system | Economy shifts | 3 | 6 | 18 | Accept Risk | Team |
10 | Technical | Purchased software can't be modified | GCVM isn't happy | System has no edit feature | 6 | 6 | 36 | Test software before purchasing | Team |
11 | Technical | Purchased software company shuts down | GCVM doesn’t have a system | Bankruptcy | 1 | 9 | 9 | Accept Risk | Team |
12 | Technical | System can't run exact reports museum wants | GCVM isn't happy | GCVM is looking for different report | 3 | 6 | 18 | Show GCVM what reports are available | Team |
13 | Technical | System received is too complex | GCVM doesn’t use system | Overthinking of needs/requirements | 1 | 9 | 9 | Bi-weekly meetings to ensure on right path | Shawn |
14 | Technical | Software doesn’t get used | Maintenance requests go back to normal | Lack of investment | 1 | 6 | 6 | Bi-weekly meetings with GCVM | Shawn |
15 | Technical | Purchase Software doesn’t meet all requirements | GCVM isn't happy | Software isn't in depth enough | 1 | 3 | 3 | Ensure software covers basis by trials | Team |
This Risk Assessment has been updated based on the meetings with GCVM and what they are looking for and where we currently are in the process. A completed Risk Management Template found in Risk Management V4.xlsx
Plans for next phase
- Get all remaining assets and buildings into MaintainX
- Obtain raw CSV output from MaintainX and create macros on data
- look into crystal ball and other reporting software
- Begin to put in real, live repair requests into the system