Page tree

Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

This page and the entire website is currently under construction as we migrate more than 2200 terms/signs from an older server to this one.

 


by

HARRY LANG


Four Decades of Research and Evaluation
      This lexicon represents many years of evolution of a science sign resource, beginning with the NTID Technical Signs Project led by Frank Caccamise to the current resource now under construction, which includes more than 2200 science terms/signs.  The evolution included funding from the National Science Foundation, summer discussions with eight deaf science teachers and two ASL linguists, constant feedback and evaluation online by teachers, deaf scientists, and interpreters, and several research studies.  In addition, the National Science Foundation "Classroom of the Sea" project with NTID collaborating with the American School for the Deaf and the University of Connecticut National Undersea Research Center (NURC) led to the development and evaluation of Marine Science signs. Collaboration with the Technical Education Research Center (TERC) in Massachusetts and with the Institute for Disabilities Research and Training (IDRT) also led to enhancement of signs. Science teachers from five schools for deaf students around the country also participated in evaluating signs for the purpose of emphasizing the importance of standardizing signs WITHIN SCHOOLS.is briefly described on this page.

    

During the 1970s and 1980s, the NTID Technical Signs Project developed videotapes and books with science and math signs. The project used a process of COLLECTING, EVALUATING and SYSTEMATIC RECORDING (CESR)
signs.

 

Image Added

First Technical Signs Project book for science and mathematics signs.

 



Second Technical Signs Book developed with the Technical Signs Project (TSP) at NTID.


We soon Over the first decade, we realized that finding the most popular signs for science terms was not the best solution. Rather, the best CONCEPTUALLY ACCURATE signs became the goal.  Discussions of the concept represented by the sign led to ongoing revisions of the lexicon.


We also realized that permanent (unchangeable) resources do such as books or videotapes did not allow the continued evolution of signs that comes from research and discussion. An online lexicon allows for replacement of videos on a regular basis as feedback is received.

The development of the current online lexicon (NTID SCIENCE SIGNS LEXICON) has been based on three National Science Foundation grants:


1) AESOP (Access to English and Science Outreach Project) - 8 regional workshops with science teachers.


2) COMETS (Clearinghouse On Mathematics, Engineering, Technology and Science)  - Asynchronous (any time - any place access) Online Resource

3) CLASSROOM OF THE SEA (NTID, UCONN, American School for the Deaf) - Marine Science signs developed over four years.

CONCEPTUAL ACCURACY - has become the most critical focus of this lexicon project.


Image Added



Like many pictures in textbooks, this one shows the orbit of the Earth around the Sun in a manner that some young people (and some older people) may interpret as elliptical, when in fact the orbit is very close closer to a circular.  In the same manner, some signs may communicate misconceptions to young deaf children. For example, the traditional sign for SHARK with the hand near the forehead may miscommunicate, especially to younger learners, that a fin is near located on the head of the animal.  The sign We avoid this sign.


Similarly, the sign for ELECTRON is often made in a manner that shows it orbiting the nucleus of the atom. Electrons do not orbit the nucleus. We are attempting to We avoid this sign for that reason.

With such a focus on conceptual accuracy as much as possible. For this reason, we welcome suggestions for improving the signs.
 
                                           
RESEARCH
RESEARCH AND PUBLICATIONS ON TECHNICAL SCIENCE SIGNS

Some research studies we have conducted on science signs are listed below:

Lang, H.G., Laporta Hupper, M., Monte, D., Scheifele, P., Brown, S., Babb, I. (2007). A
study of technical signs in science: Implications for lexical database development.
Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education, 12, 65-79.

Lang, H.G., & Pagliaro, C. (2007). Factors Predicting Recall of Mathematics Terms by Deaf Students: Implications for Teaching.
Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education, 12, 449-460.

Tedeschi, M., Lang, H.G. (Capstone Project). Recall and
Comprehension of Signs by High School Students: A Study of Two Movie Formats for an Online Lexical Database.

...

Lang, H.G., and Steely, D. (2003). Web-based science instruction for deaf students: What research says to theteacher. Instructional Science, 31, 277-298



                                   CONTINUED EVALUATION

TEN DEAF NATIVE SIGNERS WITH DEGREES IN SCIENCE/MATHEMATICS (plus two ASL linguists) spent a summer discussing and evaluating many of the signs in this lexicon.

FIVE SCHOOLS FOR THE DEAF - EVALUATED COLLECTIONS OF THESE SIGNS AND PROVIDED FEEDBACK RELATED TO THE NEED FOR STANDARDIZATION WITHIN A SCHOOL.

FOR TEN YEARS AN ONLINE LEXICON EVALUATION PERMITTED USERS TO SUBMIT THEIR OWN SIGNS AND TO RATE EACH SIGN ON A 1-5 SCALE
                 ONLINE SCIENCE SIGNS LEXICON at NTID



WE FOCUSED ON QUALITY CONTROL AND CONCEPTUAL ACCURACY
Previous evaluations have shown many different opinions about science signs.


Example:   WHALE   (Three signs). Below are some examples of feedback showing different perspectives on the three signs for WHALE.

...

I like sign 2 because it looks similar to the movements of whales in the water.


                                           COLLABORATIONS       
There are also regional variations.

COLLABORATIONS       

ASL STEM FORUM 

- THEY UPLOADED MANY OF OUR SIGNS TO THEIR WEBSITE/YOUTUBE


VCOM3D  
    -   CONTINUED WORK WITH VCOM3D HAS LED TO MORE AND MORE CONCEPTUAL ACCURACY THROUGH   DISCUSSIONS  (SOCIAL NETWORKING)
(
Several chemistry teachers at NTID and several biology teachers at Gallaudet)
                  SOCIAL NETWORKING


VCOM3d   LIFE SCIENCE   

-DISCUSSIONS OF SIGNS WITH GALLAUDET AND NTID FACULTY
EXAMPLE:     CLOTTING (LIFE SCIENCE)
VCOM3D  PHYSICAL SCIENCE
- DISCUSSIONS WITH NTID CHEMISTRY FACULTY
EXAMPLE:   

ORBITAL (CHEMISTRY)
Notes: 

Space Camp participants and interpreters might be interested in the signs developed in our category ASTRONOMY AND SPACE SCIENCE




Signs

 

HTML
<iframe id="ensembleEmbeddedContent_-qfPkeCGQU6rV7RBo5pFSw" src="https://video.rit.edu/app/plugin/embed.aspx?ID=-qfPkeCGQU6rV7RBo5pFSw&displayTitle=false&startTime=0&autoPlay=false&hideControls=false&showCaptions=false&width=360&height=202&displaySharing=false" frameborder="0" style="width:360px;height:258px;" height="258" width="360" allowfullscreen></iframe>